Durability. It may surprise you to learn that vinyl garage doors are in many ways sturdier than steel garage doors. Whereas steel doors are prone to being dented and dinged, vinyl doors are highly resistant to damage. Moreover, if scratches or scuffs do occur, they're less noticeable on vinyl as opposed to on steel.

Perhaps the ultimate contributor to an expensive garage door versus a cheaper garage door is the material you choose. Consider the texture, color, and thickness you want for your door's construction. Additional layers of insulation, and layers of steel, wood, or other materials all contribute to a grander price tag.

A new door is often worth the investment compared to cheaper alternatives like refreshed exterior paint. Functionality: A garage door's functionality gradually diminishes as it ages, and its stability will naturally be the first to go — but beyond that, it might also experience faults and breakdowns.

A fiberglass garage door is a cost-effective, low-maintenance choice that offers more damage resistance, while steel is a budget-friendly, energy-efficient option that keeps your home secure.